Estratégias jurídicas para possíveis conflitos entre indicações geográficas e marcas
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Instituto Federal de Educação, Ciência e Tecnologia da Bahia
Abstract
The phenomenon of coexistence in the market between Geographical Indication and brand
is a challenge for the Brazilian legal system, since the legislation is not able to regulate all possible
cases of conflict involving both institutes, which creates legal insecurity and enables conflict of
rights. In this work, possible legal strategies to overcome this legislative gap are investigated.
Therefore, the objective of the research is to propose a doctrinal contribution that can act in a
preventive way, helping the law enforcer in the interpretation of the legislation that involves the
theme, anticipating forms of conflicts and solutions, thus reducing the existing degree of insecurity
and avoiding conflicts of law. For the construction of legal strategies for possible conflicts
involving Geographical Indication and Brand, an exploratory research was carried out, using the
bibliographic and documentary method. The results showed that although there is no express
normative prediction for each situation that may exist related to the conflict of the analyzed
institutions, the theoretical framework that involves them is sufficient to identify ways of solving
the problem. Both the principles related to the distinctive signs and the theories based on semiotics
- although they are not enough to solve the problem, because the geographical mark and indication
have a different legal nature - can be part of the strategy to resolve the conflict. It was also found
that the IG has a superiority in relation to the brand, and that its legal protection, aims, among
other reasons, to avoid its generalization in the face of the existence of a brand that is similar to it.
The considerations suggest as a general legal strategy the following: it must be verified whether
the brand that reproduces, imitates, evokes or associates with IG, can lead the consumer to error;
it must be verified whether the use of the brand in conflict with the IG is configured as an unfair
competition practice; and, you should check if the brand contributes to the generalization of the
IG

